Dani Shapiro

On the Private Heart

I've been thinking lately about the place inside of us from which we write.  Of course, for each one of us, this place is, de facto, different.  I recently came upon these words from a Paris Review interview of Cynthia Ozick: "What do I mean by "private heart"?  It's probably impossible to define, but it's not what the writer does–breakfast, schedule, social outings–but what the writer is.  The secret contemplative self.  An inner recess wherein insights occur.  This writer's self is perhaps coextensive with one of the writer's sentences.  It seems to me that more can be found about a writer in any single sentence than in five or ten full-scale biographies."

The secret contemplative self.  The private heart.  The very phrases bring tears to my eyes.   I don't know about you, but for most of us, our daily lives take us farther and farther away from that secret self, that private heart.  A paradox central to most writers lives is that so often we spend our days not writing, not reading, not in the silence in which the secret contemplative self thrives, but rather, speaking, tweeting, traveling, facebooking, trolling the internet...doing, rather than being.

It is only in the silence that our voice emerges.  It is only in the movement of the hand across page, one word following the next, in the crafting of sentences that we know ourselves.  We can talk ourselves blue in the face, and we may be telling a certain kind of truth, but it is not the deepest truth, not the truth of our private heart.  When people ask me when I knew I wanted to be a writer, or when I "decided" to become a writer, it is this I think about.  This bittersweet pleasure, this pressure and longing to find myself on the page.  It's always been this way for me, since I was a child scribbling in my notebook.  A shape emerges.  An image, a fragment, a thought I didn't know I was thinking.

The more time I spend away from the page, the further that secret self recedes.  I know she is not always available to me.  She is a chimera, elusive, finicky, sly.  She doesn't always want to be found.  She likes to be treated with the respect she deserves.  And that respect involves sitting down.  Showing up.  Eliminating distraction.  Remembering that the writer's heart is a private heart, that our sentences are like candles in the darkness, showing us the way.

share:
  • Twitter
  • Tumblr
  • Facebook
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
Line Break
  • http://twitter.com/StarlaJKing Starla J. King

    *chills*   the "omg that is EXACTLY it!" kind of chills.  In a culture (American, in this case) that demands the ongoing opposite of what a writer needs... what a writer IS... your gentle telling of the writers' experience is always... ALWAYS... a validation thru understanding.  Thank you Dani.  xo

  • Anonymous

    My writing partner says the "chills" are affirmation of deep truth. I'm covered in them. What a lovely image of those candles leading us to our inner selves one light at a time. 

    I read your blog the way you read Virginia Woolf when you prepare to write. For me, your words act as a portal into that space, and I thank you for that.

  • http://www.adesignsovast.com Lindsey

    I have goosebumps (which seems a common reaction to this piece).  Chimera is one of my favorite words.  Oh, this is so, so true - for me the challenge is trusting that the contents of my private heart are worthy of sharing.  So often it feels like so much black muck, with some glittering shards, sure, but mostly muck.  Thanks for reminding me that regardless, I need to surrender to the urge I feel to turn inward, no matter how black it sometimes feels there.  xox

  • http://www.GoodLifeRoad.com Kathryn at Good Life Road

    Well said. The writers heart is always present even when the rest of the day calls us away from it. I can so relate to your "find myself on the page" because no matter how much I think I know about what I want to say something always comes forth from a deeper place that surprises me. Your last line about the candle in the darkness reminds me of Virginia Woolf "...The great revelation perhaps never did come. Instead there were
    little daily miracles, illuminations, matches struck unexpectedly in the
    dark."

  • Anonymous

    "Doing rather than being" resonates with me. Lately I've bee turning inward more often with yoga and meditation, and trying to be less distracted by the incessant buzz of the internet, TV, life. It's when I let my surroundings quiet down that my secret self comes forward and writing becomes as natural as inhaling and exhaling. Thanks for this post, Dani!

  • http://www.elanahalberstadt.wordpress.com ElanaH

    I agree wholeheartedly with all the beautiful comments here already. Today, after 11 days of my almost 5 year old sick at home, and following a month where my husband recovered from surgery,  and me in the role of mother, and wife, nursemaid, and all that is within that (that I was happy to do, but am tired and drained),  and not being able to write because there was no space or time, or energy to even have a clear thought, or the quiet I need to think and to write. And the bubbling inside me turning into a big storm of frustration and anger. The wanting to write, and the patience (maybe tomorrow it will be better), and the waiting. Then asking myself, how do I do this with all the distractions? Is it just me? It's noisy out there. The pace is too  fast. I'm not keeping up. Does it even matter? Everything you so perfectly described in your always eloquent posts. Today, my son returned to school. My husband is at work. I am alone. ALONE! For the first time in so long. The peace and quiet I craved, it is here. So, first, I will walk in this beautiful day to vote. Then, I will write. How marvelous to read your post today! It is the truest thing and just what I needed to help claim my time for me today. Thank you, Dani. 

  • Florasinflower

    Love this so much. Reminds me..

  • Wlerman

    It's incredible to read things related to what I am currently writing about. I feel grateful and validated. Thank you!

  • Rabbi Jill Zimmerman

    so beautiful Dani

  • http://www.unmappedcountry.blogspot.com Hope

    Lovely expression of the ineffable. I would add that I always struggle to find and describe that private heart; rarely do I feel that what I manage to put on the page expresses exactly what I want to say. I think it's because I'm always finding out more about myself.

  • http://twitter.com/musingsdemommy Musings de Mommy

    You nailed it. I have such a hard time when life competes with what I truly desire--solitary hours, my thoughts and the sentences that come as a result. inAs you point out, when different events unfold, I will sometimes feel their weight but not fully grasp their lesson. Only when I'm writing can I tease this out. 

    tI hink this part resonated with me the most: "She likes to be treated with the respect she deserves." Amen to that. 

    I feel so fortunate to read your words and benefit from your gracious insights. Thank you for sharing them here. xo

  • http://www.beth-kephart.blogspot.com Beth Kephart

    breathing more calmly as I read this.

  • http://www.aileenreilly.com/blog Aileen

    I am printing this out.  Your words are so very true.  I'm about to embark on less doing and more being, and these candles of yours are greatly appreciated for my darkness.

  • http://www.coffeesandcommutes.com/ Christine LaRocque

    I cannot tell you how important it was for me to read this right now. At this point. I'm bookmarking it in my file entitled Life Inspiration. Because this is the heart of my personal challenge, to stay true, to keep centred, to find my path. So well said, Dani. Thank you for sharing.

  • http://twitter.com/laureninwaiting Lauren Michelle

    I've been thinking about this, even before I read your post. I've lost my quiet time since I started college. Heck, I've even lost my writing time. My freshman year, I was really good about making time to work on my stories, but something happened. I let the desire deflate, and while it's still there, I keep suppressing it. I have to work on disconnecting myself. Even though I love social networking and have fun tweeting endlessly about one thing or another, it does steal you away from the time for self-reflection and meditation that's so important to a writer's creative development and growth, not just artistically, but even spiritually. Thanks for an insightful, thought-provoking post. I'm going to spend time reading through your other posts here on the sidebar. You write pretty. :)

  • Jzr

    This is so beautifully put.  A wonderful reminder and a writing to come back to time and time again.

  • Jeannie Lindheim

    Perfect!!!  also printing it out~   that is why I write and the silence is everything~  Thanks Dani~

  • Dani

    Thank you, everyone, for these wonderful responses to "On the Private Heart"!  It means more to me than I can express, especially as I work on my book, STILL WRITING, which is really about all these ideas and more.  It also affirms my commitment to continue to blog... thank you. 

  • http://www.dogwalkblog.com/ Rufus Dogg

    Isn't it interesting in a world that tells us that print is dead that the highest compliment you can pay someone who has written a piece online is "I am printing this out." Something to hold onto, perhaps a piece of the private heart that one can touch that confirms it does exist.

  • Regina Brett

    Lovely, absolutely lovely.

  • http://www.oneisnotalonelynumber.com Evelyn Krieger

    You have to be comfortable with your own silence.  Not everyone is.  That's another story....

  • http://www.wendyharpham.com Wendy S. Harpham, MD

    Your lovely post makes me think about the voice in my head (http://tinyurl.com/HS-093011.

    The private heart that strives to write something for publication addresses my reflections, insights and advice to others, whether I'm thinking about truths I know well and when I'm confused and trying to figure out something.

    Twenty-plus years ago I became a writer by default: Cancer treatments made me too sick to care for patients one-on-one, so I turned to writing to continue helping them from my perspective as physician-patient.

    For me, my private heart expresses itself not ony when sitting in front of a computer screen but also when putting dishes in the dishwasher, watering the flowers, sitting at a red light, listening to other patients at a symposium, reading others' writings on survivorship, discussing patient care with colleagues.  

    On the days I delete everything I've written since sunrise, I take comfort in knowing that my private heart still had a productive day. The struggle that yields few printed words is part of the process that takes me closer to sharing a new message with others. 

  • Lucb707

    This was a great reading.  I have felt that your pieces have been the same issue just a different date.  Thanks.

  • http://hersuburbanlife.blogspot.com/ M K Countryman

    Friday,

  • http://hersuburbanlife.blogspot.com/ M K Countryman

    This is my first year to have hours to write, more than an hour or two window.  Some days, I write so much, and other days......not so much.  But that doesn't mean the days I don't write as much that they are less worthwhile.  Sometimes, it is harder and takes longer to access that part of me that can share....when I do things to recharge - like read your blog.  Sometimes it's scary though.  My husband always asks, "What did you get done today?"  And I hear people all the time saying, "I didn't get anything done today."   I remember the day I dropped my youngest daughter off at preschool, after years of being home with children, I had 2 hours.  My friends were going shopping, going to breakfast, going to coffee, going to do errands.  I literally RUSHED home to be by myself for the two hours. 

  • Anonymous

    Once again your writing satisfies like a delicious meal.
    Thank you!