Dani Shapiro

Payday loans

On Finding a Niche

I recently came upon this wonderful quote from Anne Lamott: "In this dark and wounding society, writing can give you the pleasures of the woodpecker, of hollowing out a hole in a tree where you can build your nest and say, "This is my niche, this is where I live now, this is where I belong."  And the niche may be small and dark, but at last you will finally know what you are doing.  After thirty years or more of floundering around and screwing up, you will finally know, and when you get serious you will be dealing with the one thing you've been avoiding all along––your wounds."

For years, I railed against the idea that we write from our wounds.  It makes all writing sound autobiographical.  It seems to discount the imagination, and imply that writers simply bleed onto the page.  But I've come to see that wound is just another word for obsession, and obsession is just another word for theme, or subject matter.  We cannot get away from what obsesses us.  Why would we even want to?  Those of us who write are enormously lucky to have something to do with our obsessions, a craft, an art, that turns what haunts us into something that (hopefully) resonates for others.

In truth, I often have no idea what drives me forward when I'm writing a work of fiction.  I try to remain willfully obtuse about my themes, because to over-think, at least in the early stages, creates a self-consciousness that ruins the work.  It's only later, much later, when a story or a novel is finished, that I understand what it is that I've done, and what has driven me to do it.  And still... what is most powerful is that feeling of writing in the dark, of following that line of words, first one, then another, and slowly building something that way.  A shape emerges.  It is not our business to analyze it as it takes shape, because analysis will ruin it.  First there is a foundation, then doors, windows, a roof, furniture, a faucet dripping, a flower drooping in a vase, a child crying alone in a room... Who is the child?  Why the dripping faucet?  We keep writing forward, trusting that, in time, we will know.  In other words, we allow the imagination, along with our invisible wounds, to weave together in ways that defy comprehension, that wither under too much reflection.  This is how we find our niche.  Our own fingerprint.  The one that is ours and ours alone.  This is how our wounds become art.

share:
  • Twitter
  • Tumblr
  • Facebook
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
Line Break
  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ruth-Gonzalez/651440273 Ruth Gonzalez

    Thanks Dani, for writing this wonderful post.

  • Jimrible

    Two experiences come to my mind after reading this post.

    Two experiences come to mind after reading this post.

    One was when I was watching an interview with Bono years ago after U2 finished working on the Pop album and were about to take it on tour. Bono said he was looking forward to singing the songs to see "what I was going on about." I thought that was pretty interesting to write lyrics and figure out what they mean to you later.

    Another experience was a story I heard (and I can't for the life of me find a reference to it) about a little boy who grows up not speaking. Nothing wrong with him, he just doesn't express himself. Around the age of 11 he sits down to breakfast one morning and declares to his mother that "breakfast is cold." His startled mother turns to him and says, "You don't speak for 11 years and the first words you say are "breakfast is cold"? The little boy replies, "Well, up until now things have been pretty good."

  • http://suzanne-morrison.com Suzanne Morrison

    Wonderful post. Your blog is so inspiring and insightful. Thank you!

  • http://www.dogwalkblog.com/ Rufus Dogg

    "...we allow the imagination... to weave together in ways that defy comprehension, that wither under too much reflection." 

    I read this article in the NY TImes this morning about e-books adding music to the "experience." http://www.nytimes.com/2011/08/24/books/booktrack-introduces-e-books-with-soundtracks.html?_r=1&ref=books Champions of this technology justify it by saying it adds to the experience, enhances imagination, meets reader where they are, blah, blah, blah. I have not yet worked out all the feelings I have about this, but I am down to one thing: Parents and teachers need to teach young readers how to hear the sounds the words on the page produce through their own imagination.

    When we give up our imagination as readers, we willfully discard the skills needed to be writers. This I know for certain.

  • http://www.erikarobuck.wordpress.com Erika Robuck

    "First there is a foundation, then doors, windows, a roof, furniture, a faucet dripping, a flower drooping in a vase, a child crying alone in a room."
    I got chills when I read this. I could see the story rising around me

    On the best writing days I'm always amazed by how hours slip by without notice, how my fingers fly over the keys, and how I don't quite understand how the words made it to the page. Other days every word feels like a fight. Through this post I now realize that the good days are the days when I've been able to turn off my conscious mind. I just wish I knew how to get into the zone every day. I have my coffee/classical piano music ritual that usually helps invoke a semi-hypnotic state, but not always. 

    I love thinking about process. Thanks for this post. You've revealed something new to me.

  • Shell-kay

    My favorite line of your post:    "It is not our business to analyze it as it takes shape, because analysis will ruin it."  Exactly.  Thank you!
    I have read all of Anne Lamott, but somehow missed that quote -- which of her works is it from?

  • Anonymous

    Our niche, our fingerprint. So beautifully spoken, so aptly said. Thank you, Dani, for in mere words encouraging us to follow what it is that mysteriously emerges and to let it speak. Wonderful food for thought.
    -Jennifer

  • Dani

    Love both of these stories--thanks for sharing them!

  • Dani

    Thanks, Jennifer. 

  • Dani

    It's from Bird by Bird -- fairly far into the book.  Thanks!

  • Dani

    Erika, I so relate.  Our rituals can really help is get into the work, sometimes but not always.  I think we have to accept the idea that there is no consistency.  We can try for it, but really, some days we fight ourselves and some days pass by in a dream.  I think the important thing is that we sit down no matter what. 

    For me the routines that help these days are staying off the internet, good cappuccino, yoga, and learning a Chopin Etude a little at a time...

  • Dani

    I'm with you 100%.  Another issue with e-books is that there's a feature which allows us now to see how many people have underlined a particular passage.  Why is this useful?  Why would a reader want to know what other readers think?  It takes one out of the experience of reading itself -- which is not meant to be a communal one. 

    Thanks for stopping by. 

  • Dani

    Thanks, Suzanne!  I see that things are going very nicely for your book!  Huge congrats. 

  • Dani

    My pleasure.

  • Brenna

    This post touched me deeply, nearly to the point of tears. That sounds inadequate, but at this moment I'm not sure how else to phrase it.

  • Shell-kay

    I thought it might be that one.  Time to re-read it.

  • Judith Sara Gelt

    You've nailed one of my struggles writing memoir--the fear of "bleeding on the page," and that somehow revealing autobiographical wounds lessens my content or subject matter; that I do, in fact, stare right into my navel. Thanks for reminding me how lucky I am to reach out to others with my personal hauntings.  It's often our obsessions that connect us.

  • Dani

    That's one of the biggest difference between, say, "journaling" -- where bleeding on the page is sort of the point -- and writing memoir, which is more akin to chiseling, crafting -- writing from our wounds, yes, but with clarity and an eye toward transforming our singular experiences into stories that will resonate. 

  • Dani

    Oh, thank you, Brenna.  I'm so glad.

  • http://geezergirl.org Jeanne

    Thanks Dani... Sandra Jensen sent me to this blog of yours.  I will visit often..

  • http://geezergirl.org Jeanne

    and.. I also wanted to say that I felt a little teary eyed.  It touched my writer's yearning

  • Gpercesepe

    a friend of mine who was tortured in columbia is fond of saying, "the blessing is next to the wound."

  • Jeff Darling

    Remarkable insight Dani. I knew sooner or later I would pick up gold from you...thanks. I have passed it on to the others I know that aren't yet your friends. You really do understand writing.

  • http://www.trustingthemoment.com Jeannie Lindheim

    LOVE your thoughts and SO TRUE!!   

  • Connie Bennett

    This is a fascinating idea that we write from our wounds. Thanks for sharing!

  • Ben Sen Dan Foley

    Dani:

    I met u with Rona this summer.  I wrote a review of DEVOTION on my blog but suspect it didn't get to you.  I'm not sure I have the right email address.  It was on the cover of OS.  You can google Ben Sen's Blog, or contact me through Rona.

    Ben Sen Dan Foley

  • JCSerbia

    As a child I was physically abused--I acknowledged it and even forgave my abuser. But now that I'm working on becoming a writer-- and working on my first novel--it never fails that writer's block surfaces everytime I need to address personal issues that link back to the wounds from that abuse.
    Thanks so much for this article--I find that when I stop writing my novel long enough to address the psychological affects from the abuse--I not only continue to experience personal healing and freedom from my past--but I also continue to find my niche as a writer. My wounds ARE becoming art.

  • Dani

    I just read your lovely, thoughtful review, Ben.  Thank you!  I hadn't seen it.  It's good to hear from you.  I remember our day with Rona, Cosmo et al this summer. 

  • http://twitter.com/JanMasters Jan Masters

    I am a healer and a writer and I do both from my wounds. I don't know where inspiration, devotion and the path would emerge from if not from those tender places in me and my ability to transform lead into gold with the spiritual alchemy that seems to emerge in both fields. Thanks for this wonderful expression!!