Dani Shapiro

On Exposure

It happens like clockwork.  At every reading or event I have done in the last number of years, at some point someone comes up to me and asks the following question in a semi-embarrassed, hushed tone.  How do you deal with putting yourself...you know...putting yourself out there?  All the details of your life?  I mean, it's very brave, but don't you feel...exposed? For years, this question bothered me.  The question itself made me feel exposed, as if the person asking was pointing out that my underwear was showing, or that I had been walking around for hours (years!) with something on my teeth.

Because the truth was this.  I didn't feel exposed.  I didn't.  But I wondered if not feeling exposed by my writing--which clearly other people thought I was--meant something was wrong with me.  That I was somehow missing a gene that everybody else had, a self-protective gene designed to keep private matters private.

But now I think of the whole idea of exposure as it relates to writing very differently.  Now, when the question invariably comes up, here is my response.

You know, I didn't publish my diary, I say.  It's a tremendous privilege to have the opportunity to craft something out of one's life, to take the chaos and randomness and make order out of it.  I pick and choose what I put in my work.  Not everything goes in there--not remotely.  I only include what will serve the story, and I am always conscious that it's a story I'm telling.  I didn't publish my diary, say.  If you had read my diary, I might have to kill you.

I am, in fact, a very private person.  Sometimes, when having an intense, intimate conversation in which I sense that I'm revealing something of myself, I will feel myself grow hot, a wave of embarrassment and self-consciousness rising, literally rising to my face in the form of a bright red blush.  I don't speak easily, or often.  At dinner parties, I am often quiet unless I really have something to say.  I'm not terrific at small talk.  I have good friends who don't know about certain chapters of my life--unless they've read about them--not because I am withholding information, but because I don't tend to talk that much about myself.

And so, the exposure question is a very interesting one.  It brings to mind something that dear Frank McCourt once said at a dinner party, when his companion turned to him and asked him much the same thing.

You must feel like I know you, the woman said conspiratorially.

Darling, Frank said in his Irish accent that managed to make word sound gentle.  It's just a book.

share:
  • Twitter
  • Tumblr
  • Facebook
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
Line Break
  • Pingback: Tweets that mention On Exposure | Dani Shapiro -- Topsy.com

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Theo-Nestor/527868280 Theo Nestor

    I hadn't realized it before I read this, but when people say I'm brave for writing about my divorce, I feel they're shaming me. Like if I were a normal person, I wouldn't be so "brave."Love this post. Agree with every word. And love the every quotable Frank McCourt.

    Thanks!
    Theo
    http://www.writingismydrink.com

  • http://marianne-elliott.com Marianne

    Great response! I think it is a testament to your writing that people who read it are completely unaware of all the work, all the craft and all the careful choices that went into creating the book they ended up reading.

    I'm going to remember that response for when my memoir makes it's way into the public eye.

    Thanks,

    Marianne

  • http://www.lindawis.com Linda C. Wisniewski

    As another memoir writer and teacher, I thank you for this. After my book came out, I got some advice from people on how to handle some of the issues I wrote about! It is, in fact, not my diary, not my life. It is just a book.

  • ellie

    When they ask, it may be that they are considering writing themselves and wonder how it would feel. I know I've always wondered.

    P.S. Thank you for sharing yourself :-)

  • Spiver

    This post really spoke to me! I've also heard this question a bunch of times. I've never had the feeling that the person is genuinely wondering what it is like to speak from a very personal place. Instead, the question has a sort of prurient vibe, like maybe I'm not aware that I'm some sort of exhibitionist.

    Like you, I simply don't feel exposed. The person I've tried to tell the truth to about my life is me. Whatever anyone thinks they now know about me is 100% projection and I feel interested but not responsible.

    I'm rather shy. Quite introverted, too Somehow dialoguing with the world from within the pages of a book is just perfect. And anyway, it's just a book.

  • http://www.coffeesandcommutes.com/ Christine LaRocque

    I feel a little uncomfortable comparing my own writing, but on my blog I try hard to be very honest and frank. I share parts of myself there that I don't share any other way. The thing is, it feels less like I'm sharing because in fact I'm hiding behind the computer. It's easier to put it out there. No sweaty palms, not hot flashy cheeks, just words. It almost does desensitize.

  • Dani

    Theo, that's exactly it -- thanks for writing. Glad to see you here.

  • Dani

    Thanks for that, Marianne. And good luck with your memoir. Hopefully I'll still be here, continuing to write about the process, which interests me as much as the craft!

  • Dani

    If we were all as adorable as Frank McCourt it would be easier to get away with his perfect reply. I'm still working on it...

  • Dani

    And thanks for sharing that. You well may be right. Though there is a feeling, sometimes, of the prurience of which Susan speaks...

  • Dani

    Thanks, Susan. You nailed it -- the vibe, even though sometimes it's probably coming from a very genuine place, it still used to make me squirm, until I figured out my quick and genuine response to it.

  • Dani

    You're being honest and frank, but still you're picking and choosing your words...

  • http://www.laughonpurpose.com Ssarnak

    As someone who DID ask the question, I think it is really a testament to the fact that if you share your memoir or parts of your life, then you congruent with your authentic self. When I thinking of sharing parts of my life that I find too private, my discomfort stems from my own inability to process the events in a truthful and honest way. Perhaps, the very act of sharing them helps to come to terms with them?

  • Nina

    Thanks Dani, I have thought about this topic as well, especially after sharing personal work with classmates who I’ve just met. I believe that memoir really is not that much more different than any art in that it offers a means to convey experiences and concepts that can’t easily be expressed or don’t seem to have a place in day-to-day conversation. Through memoir you can fully realize and share your experiences on a deeper level. In that sense memoir actually offers you some level of self-protection about your most private experiences, because as you say it has been crafted and filtered from raw experience into the story you choose to share.

  • http://aspiringwriterworld.blogspot.com/ Gabriela Lessa

    What about exposing your loved ones - or even worse, the ones you certainly don't love and you're sure wouldn't allow you to mention them on a book? How do you deal with that? I've been wanting to write a memoir for a while, but I always stop at that - the fear of exposing people or even having a lawsuit coming my way.

  • http://twitter.com/RachelleGardner Rachelle Gardner

    Dani, I love your answer and I feel the same way. Many people *think* they know me (writers who follow my blog). When I go to conferences I'm surrounded by people who feel like I'm their friend. My blog had over half a million page views last year, and sometimes when I look at the numbers I DO feel overexposed. But I remind myself exactly what you said... I pick and choose my words. I don't really give all of myself.

    Recently I held a "Six Word Memoir" contest on my blog. The entries I wanted to put up for myself (but didn't) were:

    "The me you see isn't me."
    and
    "You only THINK you know me."

    So I've been focused for quite awhile on the difference between exposing yourself... and creating the illusion that you are doing so.

  • http://www.expatharem.com/identity-messages/ Anastasia

    Yes, I think it is in the writing (and rewriting) of events and thoughts and experiences that makes sharing them somehow possible. Recently I published a family story -- "Thanksgiving with Mary Jane" -- I'd only told to friends for years before committing it to paper. With each little hurdle (writing group, anthology editors, Chicken Soup readers and shoppers at CVS pharmacies, now the whole freaking internet since it was on the RedRoom homepage in November and now at my site too) I've been letting go of the reasons not to share it more widely.

  • Dani

    An interesting thought. I find that crafting parts of my life, my history, that have happened and turning them into memoir has no part in helping me come to terms with them -- I already have to come to terms with them first in order to be able to write lucidly about them. I think this is one of the fundamental differences between memoir and writing in a journal.

  • Dani

    Exactly--I think it's the honing of events, turning them into a story, rather than an anecdote or a confession or a rant, that keeps us from feeling exposed.

  • Dani

    I think the writer instantly knows the difference -- can feel the difference. I don't think it's about creating an illusion, as much as touching a universal chord with a personal story...

  • Dani

    It all depends on where you're coming from. I wrote a blog post a while back called (I think) On Revenge or On Betrayal that you might want to look up. Also, I wouldn't worry about lawsuits before writing a memoir. That's a sure fire way not to get the writing done! Write now. Worry later. Good luck!

  • Dani

    Beautifully put, Nina. Thanks.

  • http://www.musingsdemommy.blogspot.com Denise

    You know what? When I had the humbling honor to interview Kelly Corrigan when Lift came out, I asked her that VERY question. And I asked it not because I thought she'd shared too much (quite the contrary..her books, like yours, speak to the very truest parts of my experience and soul)--but because I sat in awe of people who are able to share so fluently. (Kelly's great response, by the way: "I don't share anything in my books that I wouldn't share with someone I met and connected with at a cocktail party".)

    Now I find that the grittiest pieces I write resonate the most with others. But there are parts I'd like to share, but I don't, because I'm afraid. Because my story has always been too shrouded in privacy and fear. Each day I get better. But I must circumvent the fear to be able to write it well.

    Thanks for the great conversation (and can't wait to meet you in May at Kripalu!)

  • Dani

    Sometimes what we think of as the "grittiest" may well be the most universal. Looking forward to seeing you at Kriplau. We'll be talking a lot about these issues, I'm sure...

  • http://www.krissy-mymusings.blogspot.com Evie

    I love the McCourt quote and hope to use it one day. This post resonates with me because although I've been blogging for awhile now, friends are just learning of my writings. It stung when a longtime friend told me she just couldn't read my blog...that it was like looking in my windows at night. I told her that I close the curtains when I choose to. We all walk that fine line of being naked and vulnerable every day whether we write about it or not. I started Devotion yesterday, and I said Wow aloud 3 times in the first 40 pages. I cannot wait to finish and, yet don't want it to conclude at the same time.

  • Antonia Lewandowski

    The line separating art and the raw material of real life is distinct yet almost invisible. Dani Shapiro's comments here are valuable, both for readers and writers. Wonderful clarification

  • Anonymous

    Thanks for this. A friend and I just had this conversation and I'm happy to see your take on this. I'm working on a memoir and the thought of "exposure" haunted me sometimes--until I realized that I wasn't the one feeling that way, that it was other people wanting me to feel that way. As you mentioned, writing helps me to sort things out. Now I'm convinced that by jotting down traumatic experiences, I empower myself and give a voice to someone else.

    I think that as writers, we can choose between the emotion we give, and the ones we keep close. In the end, the authenticity is what matters right?

  • http://heathergracestewart.com/ Heather

    So true. Almost everyone thinks my poetry is autobiographical. It's not, so often it's made up of composite characters. I had never read that Frank McCourt quote, but I'm going to take it and change it, "It's just a poem."
    I am so happy to have found you and your beautiful blog!

  • rognes

    Well, it's not just a book, unless what was written was treated that way, as a kind of commercial love-making for show and tell. The woman at the dinner table might have deserved the brush off, but there's something glib in the response that doesn't solve the mystery. Frank McCourt knows it’s not just a book. Or he should. My impression is that he’s fighting her off with his left hand.

    His response doesn't get at how a writer can both reveal herself completely and remain protected, and writers know this truth of revealing and yet remaining hidden hovers about them like a guardian angel. Because when you read something intimate revealed in a book, you DO actually know and feel the writer as you read it. You DO know when her touch and her cries are genuine. The genuine is her gift to you. But when you meet the writer in person as a stranger – or even as her lover --you have to scan her eyes to see if the intimacy is still there. If your beautiful thing is still on.

    Intimacy exists only in the Now. And the book may provide a Now at the reader’s discretion, but in the face-to-face the Now is at the writer’s discretion. The writer always gets to withhold the truth of herself right now, in this moment, in this potential intimacy. So the reader might stand outside her castle and holler out tales of her bedchambers, but that doesn’t mean he gets to come in.

    It is a lover’s truth. It is like running into a man that you slept with for years and yet he gives you nothing in his hello on the street. You aren't intimate with him now, in this moment, and the writer knows that the now is his refuge, his castle. He can always hide in it and retreat there. His guardian angel protects him there. Isn’t this is the beautiful and comforting truth that makes writing – and intimacy – possible?

  • Pingback: When The Writer Feels Bullied By The Entrepreneur | Cheryl Isaac

  • Pingback: Drink Talks with Dani Shapiro, author of DEVOTION | Writing is My Drink

  • http://profiles.google.com/vanessagobes Vanessa Gobes

    hi dani, i'm finding this post a little late (via hay house) but couldn't resist commenting.  :-)  

    i'm thrilled to see all of these readers identify with your experiences.  i love your return commentary - you seem
    so pure and grateful.  made me happy. 

    i'm a spiritual junkie and new age blogger.  my god-given gifts are openness and writing (and good hair).  i write about my personal and very real spiritual evolution - everything
    from my childhood nightmares to balancing my chakras to my dog pooping on the dining room table (gross).  with each story i
    post, i feel incredibly vulnerable and insanely powerful at the same
    time.  the exposure seems to work for me and my audience.

    i liken writing (specifically blogging) to stripping naked and
    streaking across a baseball stadium at the end of the 7th (not that i'd
    really know how that feels ;-) .  every time i drag my mouse to the *post*
    button it feels like a mix of adrenaline and nausea.  it's all
    hanging out for the world to see.  but in the end it's exhilarating and
    cathartic.  i think it's the universal connectedness that puffs me up -
    the sidebars with acquaintances in the frozen food section and the
    emails from random people saying, "you made me think in a new way," or,
    "i feel that way, too."  my relationships feel so much realer now.  it's magic!   peace!

  • http://profiles.google.com/vanessagobes Vanessa Gobes

    hi dani, i'm finding this post a little late (via hay house) but couldn't resist commenting.  :-)  

    i'm thrilled to see all of these readers identify with your experiences.  i love your return commentary - you seem
    so pure and grateful.  made me happy. 

    i'm a spiritual junkie and new age blogger.  my god-given gifts are
    openness and writing (and good hair).  i write about my personal and
    very real spiritual evolution - everything
    from my childhood nightmares to balancing my chakras to my dog pooping
    on the dining room table.  with each story i
    post, i feel incredibly vulnerable and insanely powerful at the same
    time.  the exposure seems to work for me and my audience.

    i liken writing (specifically blogging) to stripping naked and
    streaking across a baseball stadium at the end of the 7th (not that i'd
    really know how that feels ;-) .  every time i drag my mouse to the *post*
    button it feels like a mix of adrenaline and nausea.  it's all
    hanging out for the world to see.  but in the end it's exhilarating and
    cathartic. 

    i think it's the universal connectedness that puffs me up -
    the sidebars with acquaintances in the frozen food section and the
    emails from random people saying, "you made me think in a new way," or,
    "i feel that way, too."  my relationships feel so much realer now.  it's magic!   peace!