Dani Shapiro

On Exposure

You must feel so exposed.  I've been hearing a lot of that lately.  At readings, at speaking engagements, or even from friends and acquaintances.  How does it feel to have exposed so much of yourself? Honestly, the question itself makes me feel...well...exposed.  But having written two memoirs and dozens of personal essays over the years, I have to say that I do not feel like I'm running down the street naked.  Or that people have somehow gotten their hands on my diary.  In fact, quite the opposite.  How to explain this?

Life, as we live it, is a messy, sometimes chaotic, rambling, shapeless thing.  Even as we try to shape it--with holidays, schedules, routines, rituals--still, it remains just outside our grasp.  We can have the illusion of control, but we are not, in fact, in control of our lives--it's one of the most complex and vexing facts of being human.  Life comes at us--it keeps coming at us, constantly changing, shifting, just when we least expect it.  This too, as the great Buddhist teacher Jack Kornfield says.  This too, this too, this too.  But when a writer sits down to write memoir, one of the extraordinary, hidden gifts of that process is that through the craft itself, through the shaping, forming, editing, pruning, thinking, that writer is--for that brief moment--in the driver's seat.  With all the time in the world at her disposal, the writer is creating order out of chaos.  Clarity out of confusion.  A memoir is not a diary.  Diaries (unless they are meant for publication) are like garbage cans, collecting the detritus, the trash, the ramblings of a mind trying to sort itself out.  I would die if someone were to read my diaries.  But when a reader writes to me about Devotion, or a young woman comes up to me to talk about Slow Motion, or I stand in front of a group of people who have read my work, I feel something powerful, something that has nothing to do with exposure.  It has to do with connection.  Of one soul reaching out to another soul as the poet Jane Kenyon once wrote, and saying I've been there too.

share:
  • Twitter
  • Tumblr
  • Facebook
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
Line Break
  • kandgwalker

    I've gotten the same remarks. People say they are too private to ever think about writing their story. But how else are we to connect with one another if we don't share our stories? I was born Jewish, although both my parents were agnostic. Even though your story was different in that you went to Yeshiva, I related to your struggles. I connected with your pain. And through that, I grow as a person. So thank you for "exposing" yourself.
    Karen

  • http://katieleigh.wordpress.com Katie @ cakes, tea and dreams

    I think this distinction is really important. I don't let people read my journals, but I blog and write personal essays and am working on a memoir - all of which I intend to share with the public. So it's not the same thing - though both forms of writing are valuable in their own ways.

  • lemead

    yes, yes, yes. I don't have anything eloquent to say other than my entire self breathed a sigh of recognition here. I'm told all the time how vulnerable I make myself in my writing, and honestly I don't experience it that way. And the fact that we are simply not in control, despite our stubborn efforts to be - well, that's so true too. Thank you.

  • http://twitter.com/tracyjc10 tracy johnson colby

    Having recently finished reading Devotion as well as several other books by Dani, I must say that exposed would not be a word I would use to describe what she has written about. I think that anyone who reads with purpose must appreciate honesty( especially if reading a memoir) and certain details that give the reader more insight into the human condition of the writer, and ourselves for that matter. I have been telling all my friends as well as strangers I meet to read Devotion. Especially timely and well worth the effort. Bravo, Dani.

  • emilyonthesouthernprairie

    Great distinction. It's not a diary. I think this is true, to a degree, about social media. Does it expose information about us? Yes. But it's also a highly controlled, personally selected amount of information. We see what we want people to see.

  • Julie

    As a fellow memoirist I would agree with you completely. Once I got used to standing in front of people to read and answer questions I felt connection. The letters I receive from readers are all about searching for that connection. The writing process is where I learned what the events of my life really meant to me and that something positive could come from sharing those experiences with others. Also, by the time my book was published, time had passed. I was no longer the person who experienced the events. I had been transformed.

  • Sari

    Interesting...Glad you don't feel exposed...you certainly had boundaries and dignity when you spoke last week...even the intimate topics were discussed with a sense of honor...BTW: Did you know that "Fritz" Perls, the father of Gestalt Therapy, entitled his autobiography, In and Out the Garbage Pail?

  • Karl

    How about a collection of those essays? Just a thought :) .
    Thanks for all your writings.

  • http://www.facebook.com/danishapiro Dani Shapiro

    Thanks, Karl. Been thinking about it, actually... It's nice to hear the support.

  • http://www.facebook.com/danishapiro Dani Shapiro

    Funny title! And I appreciate your comment about dignity. It was lovely to see you there, Sari.

  • http://www.facebook.com/danishapiro Dani Shapiro

    Thanks, Tracy. It means a lot to me that you responded to my book. I hope we get to see each other one of these days! I need a Maine road trip!

  • http://www.facebook.com/danishapiro Dani Shapiro

    Karen, so true. When I think that my story, my idiosyncratic, specific, Jewish/Buddhist/Yogi seeking story, has connected with people from so many different walks of life, what it helps me to realize is that our inner lives are remarkably similar, and telling the truth about one's interior is what allows us to connect. Thank you.

  • http://www.facebook.com/danishapiro Dani Shapiro

    Thanks, Tracy. It means a lot to me that you responded to my book. I hope we get to see each other one of these days! I need a Maine road trip!

  • http://www.facebook.com/danishapiro Dani Shapiro

    Karen, so true. When I think that my story, my idiosyncratic, specific, Jewish/Buddhist/Yogi seeking story, has connected with people from so many different walks of life, what it helps me to realize is that our inner lives are remarkably similar, and telling the truth about one's interior is what allows us to connect. Thank you.