Dani Shapiro

On Being Between Things

Do you know what my least favorite question is, these days? 

What are you working on?

It's an innocent question, born out of curiosity, or simply because that's one of the things writers often get asked.  What are you working on?  Even in the best of times, I don't like this question.  When I'm in the middle of a piece of work, I rarely have the words for what I'm doing.  I become afraid that talking out loud about delicate, fledgling work might make it disappear.  I keep the following quote from Nietzsche pinned to the bulletin board above my desk:

"That for which we find words is already dead in our hearts.  There is always a kind of contempt in the act of speaking."

That's so Nietzsche.  But also so true.  If I can really articulate what I'm doing, then I'm probably not doing it.  In kitchen terms, it reminds me of what happens when you overcook a vegetable until it liquifies.  But worse than being asked what are you working on? when I'm working, is being asked when I'm not.

I am, as they say, between things.  Actually, this isn't exactly accurate.  I'm promoting Devotion pretty much full time, and given the wonderful interest in this book, I have accepted speaking invitations all the way through next fall.  It's hard to promote a book and work on a new one at the same time.  Hard--but not impossible.  Just the other day, I had a glimmer of an idea for a new novel.  And a non-fiction book I plan to tackle too.  (That's all I'll say--remember Nietzsche.)  But I also have to allow my interior life to settle.  A writer who has finished a book is a bit  like a snow globe all shaken up.  It  needs to float back down again, to allow for the possibility of clarity.

It's okay to be between things.  To rest.  To--as Grace Paley used to say--take baths.  (Grace would say that she did her best writing in the bathtub.  When I was her student, I thought she meant that she sat in the suds, scribbling--but later, I realized that she simply meant she took baths.)  To take walks.  To read, read, read.  To trust that there will be another book, and another, and another.  To have faith in the process by which the imagination asserts itself--in its own way, in its own time.

share:
  • Twitter
  • Tumblr
  • Facebook
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
Line Break
  • Hope Edelman
    Love this post, Dani. So wise and true. Over at huffingtonpost.com a few weeks ago, Wednesday Martin wrote a short piece about "Writer's Drift" (as opposed to Writer's Block) which she explained as the period between books, when writers float around trying to decide or discover or commit to whatever they'll work on next. It's an unnerving place for those of us accustomed to active engagement with a project but often a space in which ideas and creativity are free to flow.
    Like everyone here, I eagerly await discovering what you'll choose next!
    Yours between books,
    Hope
  • Benecia Aronwald
    Lately, when I need a little inspiration in the early a.m., I log into your blog and there is always something there that speaks to and feeds my writer's soul. Your words never fail to validate and inspire me. Thank you for that! Also, I loved your snow globe image. I feel all shaken up like a snow globe quite a lot these days. I wonder if that is a writer's disposition b/c we are always taking so much in and the world seems to be throwing so much more at us these days. It's taken me years to recognize and honor the need in me for the quiet time to reflect and process and I am constantly struggling to find the balance between the two. It is especially challenging when you are surrounded by people who don't get it, who don't think deeply about things and are just gobbling everything up, swallowing things whole and greedy for more. Do you know what I mean? I will carry that image with me and use it to remind myself to take care of myself - to give myself permission and time to allow the snow to settle, to "take baths."
  • barbaramathewsblanton
    Your thoughts stimulated me to try to figure out where I am right now. Within seconds a word popped into my head: fallow. That sent me scurrying to the dictionary because I couldn't remember exactly what it meant. In general it means a field that has been plowed and even tilled but not planted for a given amount of time. It is a positive thing for the soil to "rest" for a while and apparently does kill weeds. It's not in the dictionary but I seem to remember letting fields lie fallow for a while so that the nutrients are not drawn out to grow things helps enrich it for the crops to follow.

    I see it as a positive quiet state. Maybe that is where you are too, but at a different life and productivity stage. I am content to have the volume turned down a bit for a while but then I am 70, facing some unexpected health issues and need to rest in that for a bit. You seem to be using the quiet to nurture ideas, self and family besides your book tours. It's all good.
  • Thank you for reminding me of that beautiful word, fallow.
  • kandgwalker
    This post so speaks to my heart. My memoir came out one year ago and I spent most of that year promoting it. Now that I have the time and energy to devote to new projects, I feel like the snow globe you so accurately used to describe the feeling. Thank you.
    Karen
  • erikarobuck
    Ernest Hemingway never spoke about what he wrote before it was complete. It took away some of the magic. I would like to abide by the same principle, but I've never been good at keeping secrets.
  • I really appreciate this post. I'm working on my first book right now, and when people ask me about it I get all muddled and trip over my words and one would never guess that I believe in it as steadfastly as I do. Eventually I usually say, "Well, publisher's marketplace says its...." because they have a one sentence description at least. An easy nugget to explain what I'm doing even though it's such a surface explanation of everything I want my book to be. But people don't understand that, they think they asked an innocent and polite question, and they end up look at me like I have two heads.

    And, as you say, part of the work of being a writer is being a reader and an observer of life. People don't always get that and think if you are not sitting in front of your computer you are likely slacking off. It can be very frustrating indeed. As you say, so much of the process is trusting my imagination and knowing that in its own way and time, the important will emerge.
  • Dani,

    I love this line: "A writer who has finished a book is a bit like a snow globe all shaken up. It needs to float back down again, to allow for the possibility of clarity."

    I'm between things right now, and it's far harder than throwing myself into a project. Like you, I have plenty to do -- trying to land both a job and an agent -- but I still feel a little lost because I grew used to being in the middle of a book. I can't relax! And I know you're right when you say it's okay to rest. I need to keep reminding myself of that.

    Thanks for sharing.
blog comments powered by Disqus